Token Economy

by Roxane on September 27, 2010 · 30 comments

in Being A Mom,Family,Kids

I don’t have badly behaved kids.  On the contrary, I honestly believe that my children are maybe slightly above average on the discipline front.  I might be biased, which is normal I think, but I do try to see them through other people’s eyes just for a rounded perspective.  I don’t think they are perfect, but also, I don’t think I would classify them as demon spawn either.  They have their moments, but in a general sense, they are well-behaved.  They are kids though, so they cannot be expected to act in any particular fashion.  I don’t want to be a dictator, so they are left to be children when it is appropriate.  They are supposed to be mischievous and they need to be allowed to be themselves so that they can form.  Into the people that they are going to be, not who I want to mold them into.  That is the beauty in all of this.  They are individuals with built-in personalities, so it is NOT my job to tweak and chisel and buff them.

I’m going to try this.  The idea is to give the child something to work for.  The way they earn things they want is not through hard labor or chores, but exhibiting good behavior.  Of course, the whole “rewarding good behavior” tactic makes a ton of sense, but when this was presented to me, it gave me something tangible that I could manipulate to fit our personal situation.  When I can look at something physical as an example to go off of, I am much more likely to try it.  I am way excited about giving this a shot with my kids and watching to see whether or not it makes a difference.

Here’s what I’ve come up with for one of my kids.  This is our example:

The Token Economy:

Good Behavior Chart-

  • Get Dressed (1st Time Asked) _____________________10
  • Brush Teeth (morning)   _________________________10
  • Eat Meal  _____________________________________5
  • Dishes/Trash in the sink/trash can__________________5
  • Shoes Put Up   _________________________________7
  • Dirty Clothes in Utility Room______________________7
  • Toys Put Up Before Bed    ________________________15
  • Wash Hands After Potty   _________________________8
  • Flush Toilet  __________________________________10
  • Brush Teeth (bedtime)  __________________________10
  • Good Report From School________________________15

What happens here is you list positive behaviors that you want to see from your child instead of behaviors you don’t want them to exhibit.  For each achieved good behavior, the child receives the designated number of tokens which are then placed in a jar or some other transparent container.  Tokens can be anything of the parent and/or child’s choosing.  For us, it will be marbles in multiple fluorescent colors.  I can’t see how a kid could dislike something colorful and noisy, so there it is.

It’s kind of a given that if there is more good there is less time for the not so good.

POSITIVE CAUSE=POSITIVE EFFECT

Also, I’ve heard children love to be in charge of things.  This gives them that opportunity, but in a way any parent can appreciate.  It also teaches them how to prioritize, put personal values on things they desire and how to save for bigger opportunities.  Sort of a money management exercise that could benefit them in their adult lives as well.  A win-win.  I love those!

Moving on.

Buy Chart-

  • Drink of choice during dinner   __________5
  • 1 Additional book at bedtime __________10
  • Camping Trip _____________________100
  • Museum__________________________75
  • Library___________________________50
  • Park _____________________________20
  • Toys R Us ($15 budget)_______________50
  • ” ” ($25 budget)_____________________75
  • Weekend with “G”  ___________________60
  • New game for Leapster _______________85
  • New game for Wii ___________________70
  • Bunk Beds________________________500
  • Date with Mom_____________________50
  • Date with Dad______________________50
  • Vacation _______________________2000

Now, I realize some of these values might look strange, but this chart for this particular child is something I have put an incredible amount of thought into.  What am I willing to commit to?  What does he value and where do his values rank in relation with each other?  These are the most feasible Good Behavior and Buy Charts that I could come up with for this one kid.  I’m still working on the charts for the other child.  That one is going to be exhausting, so I’m working on it little by little.

I also am completely aware of the fact that the charts are not justified properly and don’t line up like I want them to, but try as I may, they refuse to cooperate.  It’s making me very uneasy.  That right there just goes to show how strange I really am.  Maybe I should offer them some sort of reward for complying…

So tell me, what do you think of this idea?  Any input or suggestions?  I would love any insight you would like to offer, so bring it on!

Vote for me @ Top Mommy Blogs - Mom Blog Directory

Related posts:

{ 29 comments… read them below or add one }

Renee September 27, 2010 at

I love this idea!
I don’t have kids at home, but maybe it’ll work for grandkid visits. Also wonder if I can adjust it to Hubby dear.
Or even at work for my employees, since paychecks don’t seem to be enough.

Reply

Roxane September 27, 2010 at

OOOH! I will make it my personal mission to come up with one for husbands of all shapes and sizes for each of us to tweak for our very own. Just you watch! YAY!!!

Reply

Lori @ In Pursuit of Martha September 27, 2010 at

Well, I’m totally okay with systems…but then, it would be WAY hypocritical of me not to be. Points? Moi? Why yes!

I had a friend who really needed to use a system this structured because it was the ONLY way her son could see this sort of behavior – as a commodity to be traded. Well, if that’s what it took to get him to stop torturing his little sister, well, ok!

And eventually, the behavior just became habit. That was really what she needed, was some effective way to turn these things into habit. She just stumbled around a bit before she hit on the right system. But once she found it, it worked.
Lori @ In Pursuit of Martha recently posted..Gone- Baby- Gone

Reply

Roxane September 27, 2010 at

But of course! I just knew you would approve =)

I wonder if the system that your friend used was closely related to this one? Hearing of success makes me optimistic. Thank you for that!

Good behavior becoming habit? Now THAT would be a dream come true.

Reply

Booyah's Momma September 27, 2010 at

Interesting! We’ve a modified version of this… kind of a “reward” chart with stickers for positive behaviour we want to encourage, but it also had a column for things we wanted to discourage (talking back, temper tantrums, etc), which resulted in “negative” stickers. It had mixed results.

I like the fact that this really emphasizes the positives, rather than putting so much emphasis on “bad” behaviour… I may give this a try!

Reply

Roxane September 28, 2010 at

I hope it works out for you! Maybe we’ll both get lucky, who knows?

I think the key to this particular one is focusing completely on the positive. I’m curious to see how well it works taking that approach.

Hey, thanks for coming by!

Reply

Cate September 28, 2010 at

This is awesome! We have tried a couple of “points” systems here at home and the kids were pretty excited about them. Unfortunately it was Hubs and me who dropped the ball and didn’t keep up – which doesn’t set a great example for the kiddos.
I think this is terrific and a great thing to do – especially the stuff they get to “buy” with their tokens! :)
We may have to look at this again since the kids are all about the stuff now – I want them to be Phineas & Ferb & Candace for Halloween. My daughter said it would cost me $50 for her to be Candace. And that’s not for the costume.. LOL
Big Love!
Cate
Cate recently posted..Kids These Days

Reply

Roxane September 28, 2010 at

I’m worried me and Tim will do the same thing, but I hope we can pull it off. It is pretty important, so hopefully I can get my mind wrapped around it.

OMG that is the coolest halloween idea ever! I think Colton and Brandon are going to be Spongebob and Patrick and I’m going to see if I can find Lily a Plankton suit. HEE!

Reply

Roxane September 28, 2010 at

I am trying a new plugin so I’m replying to this comment again. Let me know if you get the corresponding email. Fingers are crossed to the point of bruising…

Reply

KLZ September 28, 2010 at

This is so detailed! Go you!

And now, I really want some marbles very, very badly. I lost mine, you see.
KLZ recently posted..Cant Help That Day have I already used this post title

Reply

Roxane September 28, 2010 at

If you find your marbles, let me know where. I might need to look there for mine!

Reply

Tiffany @ MomNom September 28, 2010 at

This is a great idea! We use something similar with a sticker chart and when the chart is full they get to pick a prize out of a jar. The jar has little pieces of paper with prizes that HE wrote, on them.
Tiffany @ MomNom recently posted..My Husband Failed Anatomy Clearly

Reply

Roxane September 28, 2010 at

Yes! Letting the kid make the choices makes them feel like they’re in charge, so letting him pick out the prizes was a fantastic idea! YOU GO GIRL!

Reply

liz September 28, 2010 at

i like it! we just started giving kate an allowance in the last 2 weeks, though we were going to use the money to teach numbers/addition/subtraction by using it at the toy store. i like your “trade in” idea!

Reply

Roxane September 28, 2010 at

I think I like it, too! Let me know if you have good results with the money. I’ll be curious to know how it works.

Reply

Kat September 29, 2010 at

What a great idea! I love it! My girls are a bit young now, but as it sounds like a lot of work, maybe I should start making the chart up now…..I really like the trade in chart too, something that isn’t just about getting candy! (we just potty trained, so we are up to our ears in candy!) It is a good way to learn to budget too, even without it being money. The only thing I wondered about was the trips to the museum and library being so “expensive”. Do your kids like going there? As a kid I think I would never choose it because of wanting to hord my tokens while getting stuff, too. Depend on the kid though, obviously….Just wondering.

Reply

Roxane September 29, 2010 at

YES! Starting the chart now would be a wise decision ;)

The museum and the library are like gold for them. On top of that? They are some real go-getters, so I have a feeling that once they start racking up the marbles, I’m going to be taking them to the library 5 times a day. Seriously. Hee Hee.

They’ll learn eventually to hoard them, but for now, I’m not sure they know the benefits of hoarding…

Reply

Natalie September 29, 2010 at

Let me know how it works! Nothing seems to work for Tater…
Natalie recently posted..A Really Bad Combo

Reply

Roxane September 29, 2010 at

OH, Natalie!

He can’t be all that bad…?

Yes, I will surely keep you informed!

Reply

Lisa September 30, 2010 at

This is really clever- I used to do the chart thing but with stickers as rewards. That worked for about 2 days, lol. I love your reward system. Hey if it works really well, don’t forget to add in ‘massage mommy’s back’ too!
Lisa recently posted..Coleman 9941-768 Road Trip Grill updated Sat Aug 14 2010 8-02 am CDT

Reply

Roxane September 30, 2010 at

OOOOH! Good call with the massage idea!!! That will be worth like 20 pts!!!

Reply

kris September 30, 2010 at

This way too complicated a system for me, babe.

Way.

Let me know how it works.

You are all motivated and fabulous!

This would last about two days at our house.

Seriously.

Reply

Roxane September 30, 2010 at

Yeah, but your kids are older! There has to be a point where they become more reasonable without being bribed, right? RIGHT?!?!?!

Crap.

Way to crush my dream, Kris.

Reply

Missy @ Wonder, Friend October 2, 2010 at

I really like the token idea. My oldest is a great kid, but we have a few issues that we’re working on. I think this could work for him!

I had to laugh about the alignment issues driving you crazy – I completely relate!
Missy @ Wonder, Friend recently posted..My TV Boyfriend

Reply

Roxane October 3, 2010 at

Let me know if you have any luck with it!

I almost scrapped the whole post because they wouldn’t line up properly. I have issues…

Reply

Rachael Joachim October 7, 2010 at

This looks great in theory- very well thought out, I could tell that you put a lot of time into coming up with this plan. That being said, however, good luck keeping consistent for more than a few weeks. I came up with a plan for myself and my two kids and husband to follow, for 30 days, and after about 3 weeks and things were going so well, we started to slack and not worry about keeping track, we thought we had it down, and then a few weeks later, we were back to square one of not having the house straightened up before bedtime each night.
I am also a teacher, and have had various reward systems for behavior with my students, and let me tell you, it’s more work trying to keep things straight with the plan than actually enjoying the good behavior- both with my students and with my own kids. I’ve found, no matter what, if kids feel they are respected and loved, they will do whatever limits and boundaries and chores you want them to do- they won’t TELL you “yes mommy, i so want to help you clean the kitchen, then help you fold laundry”, but they’ll do it if you treat them with love and respect- both in the classroom and at your home.
I would simplify things- perhaps keep a general list of what your kids (and you!) want as rewards, and go from there. You may find yourself after a few days saying to yourself “did I give the correct amount of points when my son/daughter did so-and-so? did i record it when it happened?” Of course, if you are a very organized person, you might thrive on keeping track of stuff, so then there you go! I’m interested in reading later how it’s going!

Reply

Roxane October 11, 2010 at

I totally agree with the love and respect part! Catching more flies with honey and all that, right?

I fear that you might be right about slacking after a while, but then again, who knows? It might be just right for us. Maybe simplified it would work better, too. I guess the only way to know what will work and what won’t is to give it a go. I really appreciate your input. Thanks for coming by!

Reply

The Flying Chalupa October 8, 2010 at

I’m fascinated by this! Don’t have any experience with systems / charts yet (he’s only 2), but SOON! So please let us know how this goes! Pros, cons, etc.! Let us learn from you! :)

Reply

Roxane October 11, 2010 at

I will do my best to give a detailed account of how well it works/how horribly bad we failed at it ;)

Enjoy every second of him being 2. You’ll blink a couple of times and he’ll be 5. No joke.

Reply

Leave a Comment

CommentLuv badge

{ 1 trackback }

Previous post:

Next post: